When patients research a facelift, a rhinoplasty or eyelid surgery, they compare before-and-after photos, read reviews and ask how long recovery will take. Very few ask a simple question that surgeons think about every day: who will actually perform each part of my operation? Here is your guide to that question, why Dr. Shervin Naderi feels so strongly about it, and how to raise it with any surgeon you are considering in Reston, McLean, Bethesda or Washington DC.
Who else is in the operating room during plastic surgery?
Every operating room is a team. Alongside the surgeon there is an anesthesia provider, a circulating nurse, a surgical technologist who manages the instruments and, for longer operations, often a surgical assistant at the table.
That assistant may be a physician assistant (PA), a registered nurse first assistant or, in teaching hospitals, a resident or fellow. Their job is to help the operation run smoothly: holding retractors so the surgeon can see, suctioning, cutting sutures and passing instruments. Good assistants are a real asset, and a smoother operation can mean less time under anesthesia.
Where is the line between assisting and operating?
The line differs from surgeon to surgeon, and patients are rarely told where their surgeon draws it. Some surgeons perform every step from the first incision to the last stitch. Others hand off certain parts, and the step handed off most often is the closure.
Closure is the final stage of the operation, when the incisions are brought back together with layers of stitches. Because it comes at the end, after the structural work is finished, it is the easiest step to delegate.
Surgeons who watch other surgeons operate, at meetings, in teaching videos and in shared operating rooms, see how often that hand-off happens. It is seldom discussed outside the profession, which is why most patients never think to ask, and why it has become one of Dr. Naderi’s pet peeves.
“Patients spend a lot of time choosing their surgeon. They look at results, they read about training, they meet you. Then the last part of the operation, the part that becomes the scar, is sometimes done by someone they never met. I don’t think most patients know that can happen,” says Dr. Naderi.
Book a Consultation
Thinking about facial surgery? Meet Dr. Shervin Naderi, double board-certified facial plastic surgeon, at our offices in Reston, VA and Chevy Chase, MD.
Book a ConsultationLearn about Dr. Naderi
Call Reston (703) 481-0002 or Chevy Chase (301) 222-2020.
Why does the closure matter so much in facial plastic surgery?
In facial plastic surgery, the incision line is something you will see in the mirror for years. How it is closed has a great deal to do with whether it heals as a fine, quiet line or as a scar that later needs revision.
A careful closure is done in layers. Deeper stitches carry the tension, so the skin edges meet without pulling. The surface edges are then lined up precisely and turned slightly outward, so they settle flat instead of healing as a sunken or widened line.

Small decisions add up: which suture goes in each layer, how far apart the stitches sit, how much tension the skin can carry and when the stitches come out. The incision around the ear in a facelift, the lid crease in eyelid surgery and the incisions of a rhinoplasty each have their own needs.
“The closure is not the boring part at the end. It is part of the result. A beautiful facelift with a wide or pulled scar in front of the ear is not a beautiful facelift,” says Dr. Naderi.
Scar quality also depends on things no one fully controls, such as skin type, genetics, sun exposure and how closely aftercare is followed. The closure is the part of the scar the surgeon does control, and it is worth knowing who is doing it.

Why does Dr. Naderi close every incision himself?
Dr. Naderi closes every incision he makes. In his view, a patient who chooses him is choosing his judgment and his hands for every critical step of the operation, and the closure is one of those steps.
“If you have trusted me with your face and invested in this surgery, you should get every cut and every stitch from me. That is the standard I hold myself to, and it is what I would want for my own family,” says Dr. Naderi.
That applies to his facelifts, neck lifts, eyelid surgery, brow lifts and rhinoplasty. Even in a closed rhinoplasty, where the incisions sit inside the nose, those incisions are closed by hand, and he closes them himself. His surgical team still helps throughout with retraction, suction and instruments, which keeps the operation efficient; the steps that shape your result stay with him.

Is it wrong for an assistant to close an incision?
Not necessarily. Many assistants are experienced and skilled, and in some practices an assistant closes under the surgeon’s supervision as a routine part of the team’s workflow. Having that help can shorten the operation and the time under anesthesia. What matters is that you know it is happening, because you consented to your surgeon and deserve to know which parts of your operation, if any, someone else will perform.
“I’m not saying it’s wrong. There are excellent PAs who close beautifully. What I’m saying is that the patient should know who is doing it, and if it matters to them, they should be able to ask for the surgeon,” says Dr. Naderi.
Why don’t patients think to ask in private practice?
In an academic medical center, patients often meet residents and medical students, and they are quick to ask what part of the surgery the trainees will perform. Seeing the team prompts the question.
In a private practice, you usually meet only the surgeon. With no trainees in sight, it is natural to assume the surgeon does everything, and many surgeons do. You won’t know where your own surgeon draws the line unless you ask.
What should you ask your surgeon before facial surgery?
If it matters to you, add a few direct questions to your consultation list, whether you are planning a facelift in McLean, eyelid surgery in Chevy Chase or a rhinoplasty in Reston.
- Who will be in the operating room, and what will each person do?
- Will you personally make every incision?
- Will you personally close every incision, including the final skin stitches?
- If someone else closes, who are they and what is their training?
- Can I ask that you perform 100% of my operation?

A confident surgeon will answer these plainly. If the answer matters to you, ask for the arrangement you want before surgery day, so it is part of your plan and your consent.
Where can patients from Great Falls, Potomac and Washington DC meet Dr. Naderi?
Consultations are offered at our Reston office, 1850 Town Center Parkway, Pavilion II, Suite 551, Reston, VA 20190, and our Chevy Chase office, 5454 Wisconsin Ave, Suite 1655, Chevy Chase, MD 20815, as well as by virtual consultation. Patients from Vienna, Arlington, Alexandria and Great Falls often find Reston convenient, while patients from Bethesda, Potomac and Northwest Washington DC often begin in Chevy Chase.
Dr. Naderi has performed facial plastic surgery for more than 20 years, averages about 200 rhinoplasties a year, and was named to Newsweek’s list of America’s Best Plastic Surgeons for rhinoplasty in 2023, 2024, 2025 and 2026 and for facelift in 2026.
“Ask me anything about your surgery, including who does what. I would much rather you walk in fully informed,” says Dr. Naderi.
Whatever you decide, choose a surgeon whose answers make you feel at ease. We would be delighted to walk you through every step of your operation, from the first incision to the final stitch.
Book a Consultation
Thinking about facial surgery? Meet Dr. Shervin Naderi, double board-certified facial plastic surgeon, at our offices in Reston, VA and Chevy Chase, MD.
Book a ConsultationLearn about Dr. Naderi
Call Reston (703) 481-0002 or Chevy Chase (301) 222-2020.
Frequently asked questions
Does it cost extra to have Dr. Naderi close every incision?
No. At The Naderi Center, Dr. Naderi closing every incision he makes is simply how he operates, not an add-on.
Will a well-closed incision leave no scar at all?
Every incision leaves a scar. The goal is a fine line placed where it hides well, such as in the natural crease of the eyelid or along the curve of the ear, that continues to soften as it matures, usually over about a year.
Does this matter for rhinoplasty if I have no visible scar?
Yes. A closed rhinoplasty still has incisions inside the nose, and an open rhinoplasty adds a small incision across the columella. Both are closed with care, and Dr. Naderi closes them himself.
How do I bring this up without offending my surgeon?
Ask it the same way you would ask about recovery or results. Surgeons hear many questions, and a clear answer is a good sign. Something as simple as “Who will close my incisions?” is enough.
Can I find out afterward who took part in my surgery?
Your operative report lists the surgeon and the assistants who took part, and you can request a copy of your medical records. It is still easier to ask before surgery than to find out afterward.
Medically reviewed by Dr. Shervin Naderi, MD, FACS, double board-certified facial plastic surgeon. Last reviewed November 19, 2026.

Patient Financing
Pay Over Time with Cherry
Monthly payment plans for surgery and treatments, including 0% APR options for qualifying patients. Checking whether you qualify won’t affect your credit score.